Button Ads!             

         Learn how to draw dragons, fairies, manga and more        WILLIAM S KROGER Attorney at Law, NORML Lifetime Legal Member,           GrowStoreFinder.com Grow Shop Directory   1-15-2014  
                using our free step-by-step drawing tutorials 4-26-13          Marijuana Legal Defense, State and Federal Courts 10-13-13                             Local grow shops and hydroponic store locator with reviews

                                                                                                              Mega Text Ad’s Spaces Available!   

                                               Read Here Online All The Fast Breaking Pot News Posts, Medical Marijuana News, Pot Legalization, Cannabis News Reports!
                                                                       No Twitter Or Facebook Account Is Even Needed!     

                                                                                   Marijuana Reciprocal Link Exchange For Quality Marijuana Websites!                                           
 *****************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************

  We Update Daily!

   Custom Search

Chris S. Kenoyer. Owner
MMJ Patient, Medical Activist,  Online Patients Advocate, 
Online MMJ News Journalist 

My Personal Medical Bio 

Follow Us Now On Twitter
@MedicalMMJMan 

  Tweet This Page

Or Follow Us Now
  On Facebook

        Email Us Here
olpwebs@yahoo.com  

Or Email Us Securely Here
MedicalMMJMan@countermail.com 
NEW 100% Encrypted Email Server

OLP’s Free MMJ News EList  
Get The Latest In MMJ News

All Press Contact Info For Us!

 Is CBD?  A Possible Cure For
Breast Cancer..? And All The Other
Many Forms & Types Of Cancer..?
Learn More About " CBD" Here

***************************

Advertise Here On OnlinePot
Rates As Low As  $50 a Year
24/7 – 365 Days A Year Of Sales! 

***********************************

Website Navigational Links
 

Main Start Page 2

**************************

*********************************

Parody’s Cartoons US 
Government Grown Pot,
Term Papers, School 
Reports, & Thesis’s On  
Marijuana & Cannabis

*********************************

Amsterdam A to Z

********************************

Canadian Marijuana Websites

*******************************

*****************************

Co-Ops, Clinics, Dispensary’s 

*****************************

Marijuana Doctors & Clinics 

****************************

Pot Cooking Recipes

****************************

Drug Testing A To Z

***************************

****************************

Pot Songs Video’s

****************************

100’s Of Grow Guides  

***************************

Hash A- Z

***************************

Cannabis Legal Info, Drug 
Lawyers, State, Federal Laws, 
State  & Supreme Court Rulings

**********************

POW’s Of The MMJ War!

Other Marijuana Websites 
 Websites Link Exchange!

****************************

Medical Marijuana Studies, 
Research Report’s, Medical
Cannabis Clinic Study’s

****************************

Parody’s & Cartoons  
When We All Need A Good Laugh!  

****************************

Avoiding Online MOM Scammers
 Newly Re-Updated Info!

*****************************

The Politics Of Contraband 
Medical Marijuana In The Mail?

******************************

The Hall Of Shame Section
The Online MOM Scammers 

*****************************

Online MOM Providers Ads

****************************

Politicians & Voters Rights

****************************

Medical Marijuana, Strains 

****************************

The OG  Marijuana Strain Guide

****************************

800+ FAQ Growing Questions

****************************

Patients Spiritual Guidance,
Free Online Crisis Help Center 

****************************

Online Marijuana Seed Banks

****************************

Maximum Security Section 
      Just Updated!    

*****************************

Traveling Tips, Guides, B & B’s

****************************

Vaporizers A To Z

*****************************

Online Pot Video’s & Movies

**********************************************

Please Visit Our Sister Websites!

Maine Patients Coalition.org

Reefer Madness Teaching
Museum.org

Listen Right Here Online! 
To Original 1930-1950’s
Reefer Madness Propaganda 
Radio Shows And Programs
Before TV There Were 
"Radio Stars"

*********************************

Legal Disclaimer

Guest Book

Translate Text or Web Page Go To:
Language Tools Google Translations

Article Submissions &  News
Reports Are Always Gladly
Accepted Here.

  1999-2013 Copyright © 
  All Rights Reserved.

OnlinePot assumes no legal liability for any products, or information or  
news posted, services offered,  Or
any contests or give away’s offered.

The US Freedom Of Information Act 
Automated Letter Generator "FOI"

A Fully-Automated Fill-in-the-Blanks FOI 
"Freedom Of Information Act Request" Letter Generator

                 Return To OnlinePot’s Legal Section Main Page       

http://www.rcfp.org/foi_lett.html An Automated Form for FOIA Request
 fill in the blanks & it will auto make it for you!

USING THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT a Step-by-Step Guide An American Civil Liberties Union Publication

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction

 

FOIA Basics

How does FOIA work?

What is an Agency?

What are Agency Records

You Can Get a Wide Variety of Information

About the Privacy Act

FOIA Exemptions

Access to Agency Records

Any Person Can Make a FOIA Request

Response Times

Cost

Making Your FOIA Request

Describing What You Want

Planning a Strategy

Make Requests Specific

Drafting Letters, Keeping Records of Correspondence

A Bad FOIA Letter

Understanding the Agency Response

A Good FOIA Letter

Fees and Waivers

Making an Appeal

Sample Letter Appealing Exemption

Sample Letter Appealing Fee Waiver Request

Court: The Last Resort

Working with Lawyers: Timeframes, Fees

Low- or No-Cost Advice

Federal Government Agency Addresses

Free Information for Our Free Country

"A popular government, without popular information, or the means of acquiring it, is but a Prologue to a Farce or a Tragedy – or perhaps both. Knowledge will forever govern ignorance, and a people who mean to be their own Governors must arm themselves with the power which knowledge gives."
– James Madison

An informed electorate "must stand ready to sound the alarm when necessary to point out the actions in any pernicious project."
– Alexander Hamilton

The ACLU has long argued that government secrecy about its operations endangers individual liberty. For example, in 1954 the government denied that lethal radiation had resulted from nuclear bomb tests in the South Pacific. News media that attempted to discover the truth about the tests ran into a wall of government silence. In response to this impasse, the ACLU commissioned a report, "The People’s Right to Know: A Report on Government News Suppression" which urged that increased media access to government records was necessary to protect democracy. During the next decade, the ACLU continued its campaign to pass laws that would enable citizens to "know what their government is up to." The culmination of the fight was the passage of the Freedom of Information Act.

The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) was passed by Congress in 1966 and amended in 1974. Based on the premise argued by Madison and Hamilton that openness in government will assist citizens in making the informed choices necessary to a democracy, FOIA creates procedures whereby any member of the public may obtain the records of the agencies of the federal government. The purpose of this Guide is to help you exercise your right to "open agency action to the light of public scrutiny." This publication contains detailed information, instructions and sample letters designed to help you make an effective FOIA request. We hope that this step-by-step guide will serve you well, and we invite you to learn more about the ACLU and its mission to defend the Bill of Rights for all our nation’s people.

We hope you will visit our website at http://www.aclu.org to see up-to the-moment information, news briefs and other resources on civil liberties issues. Or call ACLU Publications at (800) 775-ACLU for more information about other resources that may be of interest to you.

If you would like more information about the ACLU, including membership information, please write us at ACLU, 125 Broad Street, New York, NY 10004.

FOIA BASICS

How Does FOIA Work?

Section 552 (a) of FOIA directs government agencies to disclose certain types of records and describes the manner of disclosure required.

Subsection (a) (1) lists records that must be published in the Federal Register. These include –

• Description of the agency’s organizational structure – central office and field offices
• Description of the procedures that are set up to give the public access to the agency records – including where the records are located and the name of the custodian of the records
• General description of how the agency functions and its decision-making process
• The agency’s rules of procedure – including a description of agency forms and where you can get them
• The agency’s general policies

Subsection (1) (2) lists records that must be made available for public inspection and copying-

• Final decisions in particular administrative cases
• Policy statements that the agency uses, but hasn’t published in the Federal Register
• Internal manuals written for the agency’s staff that affect members of the public
• An index of the kinds of information that must be made public

Subsection (1) (3) contains a catch-all provision requiring disclosure of records not covered by (a) (1) or (a) (2). Courts have held that these provisions are to be interpreted broadly to achieve Congress’ goal of full disclosure.

What is an "agency" ?

FOIA defines an agency as –

• The agencies, offices and departments of the Executive branch of the federal government such as the Defense Department, the Office of Management and Budget, and the National Security Council
• The independent federal regulatory agencies such as the Federal Trade Commission or the Environmental Protection Agency and the Federal Communications Commission
• Federal government-controlled corporations such as the U.S. Postal Service, the Tennessee Valley Authority, the Smithsonian Institution, the National Railroad Passenger Corporation (Amtrak) and others

Additional independent federal regulatory agencies are the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the Federal Communications Commission.

Although FOIA applies only to agencies of the federal government, every state has laws guaranteeing citizens access to the records of state agencies.

What are "agency records"?

A few examples of the wide variety of records that citizens have sought under FOIA include requests from the Food and Drug Administration for health and safety reports on silicone breast implants; from the Immigration and Naturalization Service for information that would help locate and help insure the safety of Haitian refugees who had been deported; from the Department of Commerce for statistics on boycotts; from the Atomic Energy Commission for the names and addresses of military service members who participated in nuclear weapons testing; from the Department of the Navy for an inventory of Native Hawaiian graves; and from the FBI and the CIA for records on the assassination of President Kennedy.

You Can Get a Wide Variety of Information

Two basic types of information are available under FOIA. First, you can get information about how the agency operates, what actions it has been taking, how it has been spending its money, and what statistics and other information it has collected on any subject. Citizens routinely request and receive records relating to public health, environmental hazards, consumer product safety, government spending, labor relations, business decisions, taxes, history, foreign policy, national defense and the economy.

The second type of information that citizens often request is any records that the government has about them.

But You Can’t Get All Kinds of Information

Although the goal of FOIA is full disclosure of government records, Congress concluded that some confidentiality is necessary for the government to function.

The FOIA does not apply to the following federal entities: –

• Congress
• The Federal Courts
• Executive Office staff such as the White House Chief of Staff and others whose sole function is to advise and assist the president

Requests cannot be made under the FOIA to the following, as the Act only applies to federal government agencies. –

• State and local government agencies
• Private businesses
• Schools
• Private organizations
• Private individual records

FOIA Exemptions

A federal agency can refuse to release certain types of information. There are nine legal categories that are exempted from FOIA under section 552(b) of the law.

The FOIA requires an agency to provide you with a "reasonably segregable" (easy to excerpt) portion of a record after the portions which are exempt have been deleted from it. This means an agency can’t withhold an entire document just because some portions of the document are exempt.

Exemption One –
National Security

Agency records which "reasonably could be expected to cause damage to the national security" if disclosed, are exempt.This kind of data usually includes –

• Military plans
• Weapons
• Scientific and technology data that relates to national security
• CIA records

Exemption Two –
Internal Agency Rules

Information related solely to the internal personnel rules and practices of the agency. This is not usually of great interest to the general public, but in some instances the courts have ruled it is of interest to the general public, and has ordered its release. Examples of this have included Air Force handling of honor code violations, and training manuals for Occupational Safety and Health Administration compliance officers.

Exemption Three –
Governed By Other Statutes

Information that is specifically exempted from disclosure by another statute. Laws have been passed making personal tax data, CIA structure, charges of employment discrimination, identifiable census data and other types of information confidential. The agency ought to specify which statute they are referring to when they give this reason for denying a FOIA request.

Exemption Four –
Business Information

Trade secrets, commercial or financial information, confidential information, and information obtained from a person. An agency must prove the information involves –

• Trade secrets including
  sales statistics, inventories, customer lists, scientific or manufacturing processes or formulas, material protected by attorney-client, doctor-patient or lender-borrower privileges, etc.
• Privileged or confidential information, the disclosure of which would make it difficult for the government to obtain necessary information in the future

  -or-

• Would substantially harm the person from whom the original information was obtained. The government agency usually has to pledge that the person who provided the information asked for it to remain confidential, and prove that the information you want is not customarily available to the public
• Information obtained from a person (or corporation or organization) as opposed to from a government agency

Sometimes Exemption 4 leads to what’s called a "reverse FOIA" lawsuit. This means the person or organization that provided the original information will seek to prevent the federal agency from releasing the information to you.

Exemption Five –
Internal Government Memos

These are interagency or intra-agency memos or letters that concern confidential communications between an attorney and a client, or information compiled in preparation for a trial.

Materials involving advice on recommendations or opinions which are part of the process of government decision-making.

Exemption Six –
Private Matters

Personnel files, medical files, and other files that would lead to an invasion of personal privacy if released, are exempted.

Exemption Seven –
Law Enforcement Investigations

Any data that is compiled for law enforcement purposes, if releasing it would –

• Interfere with enforcement proceedings
• Deprive a person of the right to a fair trial or an impartial jury
• Constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy
• Disclose the identity of a confidential source such as a state, local or foreign agency, or a private institution which had provided information on a confidential basis
• Disclose investigative techniques or legal procedures
• Endanger the life or physical safety of an individual

In order to claim any of these exemptions, the agency must prove that the records were compiled for law enforcement purposes. Almost all FBI files are exempt because the courts have generally ruled that they are compiled for law enforcement purposes.

Exemption Eight –
Regulation Of Financial Institutions

This exemption pertains to records related to the examination, operation or condition of certain financial institutions which are subject to federal regulation. Examples of such institutions include –

• Commercial, savings, and investment banks
• Trust companies
• The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
• The Federal Reserve System
• The Federal Home Loan Bank Board

This exemption does not apply to organizations, such as the Stock Exchange, which are not federal agencies.

Exemption Nine –
Oil Wells

Geological and geophysical information concerning oil well locations. Examples include maps or charts, and files belonging to the Department of the Interior’s Bureau of Land Management and the Department of Energy’s Federal Power Commission. Oil well information is also protected by Exemption 4.

It is important to remember that these exemptions are not mandatory, but discretionary. That means an agency can choose to release records to you even after it has determined the records fall within one or more of the above exemptions.

Access To Agency Records

The FOIA provides access to all "agency records," except those which are specifically exempted (see "Exemptions" section of this guide for more information). The FOIA does not define the term "agency record," but the courts have interpreted it to mean printed documents or other information-bearing materials – such as photographs, computer tapes, or databases that satisfy the two following conditions –

• The agency record must already exist and have been created or obtained by a federal agency; FOIA does not require an agency to create a record just to satisfy your request.
• The record must be within both the possession and the control of the federal agency at the time you make your FOIA request. An agency does not have to retrieve a requested record it doesn’t possess at the time your request is made.

An agency has "control" over a record if it has the power to dispose of it.

You have the right to obtain this information from these agencies even if they can be collected from another source.

Any Person Can Make A FOIA Request

The FOIA permits "any person" to request access to agency records. "Any person" includes –

• U.S. citizens
• Permanent resident aliens
• Foreign nationals
• Corporations and unincorporated associations
• Universities
• State and local governments and members of Congress

A Quick Response Required

The FOIA requires an agency to decide within ten working days whether to comply with a FOIA request and to inform the person making the request of the decision and of the person’s right to appeal a refusal to provide information to the head of the agency. An agency has 20 days to respond to an administrative appeal. If it upholds the decision to refuse to provide the information, it must inform the person requesting it of the right to appeal to a federal court.

An agency may take an additional ten days to respond to the initial request or the appeal in "unusual circumstances." This usually means the agency has to get the records from its field offices, or has to process a large volume of separate records, or it has to consult with another agency or two or more of its components in order to satisfy your request.

And If It Takes Longer Than That…

Unless the agency shows that "exceptional circumstances" exist, and that it is actively trying to meet your request, you have the right to pursue your request in federal court. Even though this is the law, in practice, the courts usually allow the agency to take more time to fill your request provided they take all requests on a first-come, first-served basis.

If this happens, the agency will usually write to you within two weeks telling you your request has been placed in line and will be processed after a delay. (See "Understanding the Agency Response: The Agency Tells You to Wait," p. 19.)

How Much A FOIA Request Costs

Three types of fees may be charged for FOIA requests –

• The costs of searching for the documents
• The costs of reviewing the documents to decide if they should be included in the response to your request
• The costs of duplicating the documents

Your fee will depend on what kind of request you are making –

• If you are making a request for "commercial use," you can be charged all three types of costs
• If your request is not for "commercial use," you will only pay the search and duplication costs
• If your request is on behalf of "an educational or non-commercial scientific institution" or as a "representative of the news media," you will only pay duplication costs. Any person or organization which regularly publishes or gives out information to the public can be considered as "news media." Many public service organizations, therefore, meet this definition.

Before you make your FOIA request, be moneywise – Ask the agency’s FOIA office for the current agency fee schedule. It will explain the cost of different types of searches (manual versus computer, clerical versus professional, and the like). It will also tell you the cost per page for photocopying. Fees can vary widely from agency to agency, and even within the same agency, for similar or identical requests. Let the agency know in advance how much you are willing to pay for the requested information.

Sometimes an agency will waive the fee. This will happen on a case-by-case basis if the request is considered to be in the public interest, which means the information will significantly help the public understand the operations or activities of the government agency. (See sample FOIA request letter, p. 17, for more information.)

In any event, fees for the first two hours or first one hundred pages of duplication in non-commercial FOIA requests are waived. And unless you have failed to pay a previous FOIA request, your advance payment cannot exceed $250.

Making Your FOIA Request

Where To Write

The first thing you need to do is decide which agency you are going to send your request to. If you are not certain about which agency has the information you are seeking, you should go to the library and check the descriptions of the various agencies in publications like the United States Government Organization Manual (US Government Printing Office), or call the local office of your representative in Congress. The most common agencies are listed at the end of this guide.

Once you have narrowed down the possibilities, you might want to call the FOIA or the public affairs office of those agencies for more specific information.

If you think you know which agency has the records you are interested in, get the specific mailing address for its FOIA office. A few of the major agencies’ FOIA offices are listed at the end of this guide, but any agency’s FOIA office can be easily found. Just call the agency or look up the agency’s FOIA regulation in a book called the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) which you can find at any law library and many public libraries, and on the Internet at: http://www://law.house.gov/cfraddr.htm.

Describing What You Want

Your request must "reasonably describe" the records you are seeking. This means the description must be specific enough that a government employee familiar with the agency’s files will be able to locate the records within a reasonable amount of time and without an unreasonable amount of effort.

You don’t have to explain why you want the information you are seeking – but this explanation might be necessary if you want the agency to waive its fees or comply more fully with your request.

The more precise and accurate your request, the more likely you are to get a prompt and complete response, of course, and the lower the search fees will be.

An agency will contact you if it needs more clarification.

Planning Your Strategy

Here are some tips for planning your FOIA request –

• Try to limit your request to what you really want. If you simply ask for "all files relating to" a particular subject (including yourself), you may give the agency an excuse to delay its response, and you risk needlessly running up search and copying costs.
• If you know that your request involves a great volume of records, try to state both what your request includes and what it does not include.
• Be as specific as possible. Cite relevant newspaper clips, articles, congressional reports, etc. If the records have already been released, let the agency know the date, release number, and name of the original requester.
• Let the agency know if you’d like to receive information in a particular order. Materials could be reviewed and released to you in chronological or geographical order – or you may simply not want to wait for all the records to be reviewed before any are released.

Make Requests For Personal Files As Specific As Possible

Be sure to include –

• Your date and place of birth
• Social Security number or other identifier
• Any previous names or nicknames
• Any previous addresses or places and dates of foreign travel

• It can also be helpful to mention the nature of your relationship with the agency (former employee, participant in an agency program, etc.) Include the dates of your involvement.
• You may want to state where you lived and/or were active – some files will only be available from an agency’s field office. In this case, you should ask the agency to check the relevant field office’s records.
• Write a separate letter requesting a field check. Some agencies do not systematically carry out these field checks, even when asked. For the FBI headquarters, for example, separate letters must be written to each field office.
• Remember to make the request under both the FOIA and the Privacy Act.

Drafting Your Request Letter

Now we are going to look at some sample letters and some helpful tips for writing your request letter.

Keep Records Of Your Verbal And Written Correspondence

• Be sure to keep a copy of all correspondence to and from the agency. You’ll need it if you write an appeal or go to court later.
• Take notes during all phone conversations – their date, what was said, who you spoke to, etc. Follow phone conversations up with a letter addressed to the official you spoke with. Confirming phone conversations in writing will help ensure there are no misunderstandings, and it is also useful if your request needs to be forwarded to another office or agency. Written notes can also clear up any misunderstandings that might arise.
• In general, it can be useful to establish a regular contact in the agency’s FOIA office who you can ask for by name, if this is possible.

A Bad FOIA Request Letter

A Good FOIA Request Letter

Your envelope should be marked: "Attention, Freedom of Information/Privacy Act Unit." If your request is made solely under the Privacy Act, state on the envelope, as is appropriate: "Privacy Act Request" or "Privacy Act Correction Request." Request letters without such markings are frequently held in an agency’s mailroom. A list of commonly used addresses appears at the end of this guide.

Understanding the Agency Response

It is possible that the agency will promptly release all of the information you are seeking. But it is more likely that you will receive one of the following responses.

1.THE AGENCY TELLS YOU TO WAIT
As we’ve already mentioned, government agencies are required to fill your request within ten working days unless they qualify for an "unusual circumstances" extension. Many agencies meet their deadlines, but others are notoriously slow. When dealing with a backlogged agency, you could wait up to three months before you hear anything, and they may occasionally take years before a final response is made.

An agency may initially acknowledge one or several of the following things –

• Your request has been received and is being processed
• A search for the records you’ve requested has begun
• The fees for your request are being calculated

Some agencies may warn you that there is an administrative backlog of requests, and ask you to wait your turn. Even though this delay violates the Act’s time restrictions, it’s best to try to wait patiently; the agency will assign you a wait number.

If you experience a wait, here’s what you should do –

After you receive your wait number, call or write the agency’s FOIA office and try to get them to commit to a release date for your information – within four to six weeks. Tell them that if there is no action by this date, you will interpret their "non-denial" as being an outright denial, and you will appeal.

Whatever the cause of the delay, don’t hesitate to inquire about the status of your request or about the agency’s filing and search procedures in general.

If your follow-up inquiries are ignored, send an appeal letter. According to the FOIA, an excessive delay in complying with a request constitutes what’s called a "denial in effect." Keep records of your written and phone correspondence with the agencies. These can be useful if you have to write an appeal or go to court – you will be able to show you did everything you could to comply with the law.

Technically, the FOIA entitles you to go straight to court if the agency does not produce the records you want within the proper time limit, but unless you have a pressing need for the data, you should send a letter of appeal first. (See the "Appeals" section for full information on this process.)

2. "YOUR DESCRIPTION OF THE REQUESTED DOCUMENTS IS INADEQUATE"
If you get this response, it means you probably did not give enough specific identifying information. Give the agency the benefit of the doubt and rewrite your request. You can try to call or make an appointment with the official processing your request to get more help.

3. "THE REQUESTED MATERIAL DOES NOT EXIST"
If you are reasonably certain the records you’ve requested do exist, and if your request letter was clear and informative, you should try to do more research. Are there news reports, congressional hearings or court records that describe the information you want more clearly?

Rewrite your request, giving the agency more guidelines and clues for where they might find it. Try to be as patient and understanding as you can; some agencies are short staffed or have disorganized filing systems.

4. "SOME OR ALL THE MATERIALS ARE EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE"
You should keep certain aspects of FOIA in mind as far as exemption claims are concerned. FOIA exemptions are discretionary, not mandatory – an agency is not required to withhold information.

Agency officials can choose to waive the exemptions and release the material, unless another statute specifically restricts that disclosure.

The agency can’t withhold an entire document or file because some portion(s) of it is exempt from disclosure. The agency must release any non-exempt material which can be reasonably extracted from the exempt portion(s).

The agency must explain its reasons for determining that an exemption applies to any particular information.

• You have the right to contest any exemption claim. You can file an administrative appeal to a higher agency official. And if this fails, you can file a lawsuit. The federal court must conduct a full judicial review of the agency’s claims and it is up to the agency to justify its denial of your request.
• The exemptions must be narrowly applied, since the FOIA was created to maximize public access to agency records
• Even if the agency releases substantial portions of the material you’ve requested, you can appeal the decision to "sanitize" the rest. You can also request a detailed justification for each deletion.

Fees And Waivers

If you are charged an excessive fee, write the official who responded to your request and ask for an itemization of the charges.

If you are denied a waiver, or if the agency gives you an unsatisfactory fee reduction, press the agency official to justify these actions by requesting a full explanation of the reasons why this decision has been made.

You can also file an appeal and later go to court if you are not satisfied with your fee reduction.

MAKING AN APPEAL

Whatever the problem with an agency’s response, you have the right to file an administrative appeal to higher agency officials. There is a good chance your appeal letter will get results because for one thing, senior officials are often less anxious than their subordinates about making decisions to disclose agency records. They are also usually in a better position to take matters of policy into consideration.

Sample Letter Appealing An Exemption

Like your FOIA request letter, the appeal letter can be written by yourself, but a lawyer’s advice may be useful. Furthermore, a lawyer’s signature may convince the agency that your are serious about going to court to pursue your request.

Many more specific sample letters are found in the ACLU handbook, Your Right to Government Information. Call ACLU Publications at 1-800-775 ACLU to order a copy of this useful resource.

Sample Letter Appealing Fees Or Waivers:

ADDRESSES

The Honorable _______________
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, D.C. 20515
(Switchboard number: (202) 224-3121)

The Honorable _______________
U.S. Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510
(Switchboard number: (202) 225-3121)

You may also inform the two congressional committees that oversee the administration of the FOIA; again, enclose copies of your correspondence with the agency.

Subcommittee on Government Information Justice and Agriculture Committee on Government Operations U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, D.C. 20515
(202) 225-3741

Subcommittee on Technology and the Law
Committee on the Judiciary
U.S. Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510
(202) 224-3406

Court – The Last Resort

After you have exhausted the administrative appeals process, your last recourse is to force the agency to release the documents by filing a lawsuit. If you are determined to file a FOIA lawsuit, there is a lot of information you will need. The ACLU handbook, Your Right to Government Information, provides very useful preliminary information about FOIA lawsuits. Another ACLU publication, LItigation Under the Federal Open Government Laws, is a resource you or your lawyer will want to consult. (See p. 16.)

In addition, there are some law firms, public interest groups, and law schools that may assist you, and even represent you in court for a nominal fee or no fee at all. (See "Low Cost or No Cost Representation," p. 26.)

Take A Deep Breath And Count To Ten

You should probably wait until your request has been ignored or excessively delayed before filing a suit. Although the law says an agency has ten working days to respond to your request, judges do not look favorably on lawsuits that are filed in haste – send an appeal letter first, to be sure you’ve exhausted your administrative remedies. There is a six-year statute of limitations for suing under the FOIA. This means that you have to file a lawsuit within six years of the date you made your request – even if you have received an incomplete response from the agency. For the Privacy Act, the statute of limitation is two years.

How Long Will A Lawsuit Take?

Although the law requires federal courts to give priority to FOIA suits, they can still take about a year, and maybe two or three years if a lower court decision is appealed to higher courts. Be warned, the government may use all kinds of courtroom maneuvers to delay or prevent mandatory disclosure – you have to decide how far you want to take your request.

Lawyer? No Lawyer?

You will probably want to consult with a lawyer to see what your chances are of winning a lawsuit. While you can file the suit pro se (for yourself), it’s probably wise to have a lawyer represent you because FOIA suits involve complex, highly technical interpretations of the law. When you are seeking legal assistance, all correspondence, notes and other background material concerning your FOIA request should be in good order. Attorneys filing suit in federal court are required to certify, under risk of sanctions, that the reasons for the suit are well-grounded in both fact and law, and that the action is not being taken for improper purposes, such as harassment or delay.

Look for an attorney who has experience in federal practice, and in the FOIA in particular.

If you do want to represent yourself, the ACLU’s invaluable technical manual and reference book, Litigation Under the Federal Open Government Laws, can help you. Call ACLU Publications at (800) 775-ACLU for information on ordering this resource.

Who Pays The Attorney Fees?

The FOIA permits a judge to order the federal agency to pay attorney fees and court costs if you, the plaintiff, "substantially prevail" in the lawsuit. This means you must win the release of some significant portion of information that has been withheld, or at least a ruling that forces the agency to comply with some requirement of the law. But you must keep in mind that the judge can use discretion and decide to deny any award of attorney fees even when you have "substantially prevailed."

Low-Cost Or No-Cost Advice Or Legal Representation

Such groups are invariably understaffed, underfunded, and over-committed, so don’t expect immediate or certain attention. Remember, although you may attach great importance to the documents you seek, it is up to the attorneys (who are being asked to take the case for little or no money) to decide whether the case raises issues that are sufficiently important to justify committing their organizations’ limited resources.

Public interest groups like the ACLU, the Freedom of Information Clearinghouse, and others may nonetheless be able to provide information and encouragement through the request and administrative appeal stages, and may be able to refer you to a private attorney if you need representation. You can contact these organizations in writing for information about court decisions, the exemption provisions, trial strategy, legal representation and other aspects of the FOIA.

AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION
Your local ACLU affiliate nearest you can provide assistance with your FOIA or Privacy Act request. These ACLU offices may also give you information about state FOIA or "open records" laws, if you are seeking state or local government records. Be advised that a response may take several weeks.

The National ACLU office can give you the address and phone number of the nearest affiliate. Check our website at http://www.aclu.org or write us at –

ACLU
125 Broad Street
New York, N.Y. 10004

ACLU
122 Maryland Avenue, N.E.,
Washington, D.C. 20002

THE CENTER FOR NATIONAL SECURITY STUDIES (CNSS)
(sponsored by the Fund for Peace) has had much experience with the FOIA, mostly in matters relating to national security and intelligence records.

2130 H Street, NW, Suite 701
Washington, D.C. 20037
(202) 994-7060
http://www.fundforpeace.org/cnss.htm

THE FOIA SERVICE CENTER
The FOIA Service Center is a joint project of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press and the Society of Professional Journalists, Sigma Delta Chi. The Center primarily assists journalists with FOIA questions and is located at –

1735 "I" Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION CLEARINGHOUSE
The Freedom of Information Clearinghouse, a project of Ralph Nader’s Center for the Study of Responsive Law, gives legal and technical assistance to public interest groups, journalists, and individual citizens using the laws granting access to government-held information. Please write to –

P O. Box 19367
Washington, D.C. 20036

FUND FOR OPEN INFORMATION AND ACCOUNTABILITY, INC.
Publishes pamphlets and a newsletter and assists individuals and organizations with FOIA matters –

239 Waverly Place
New York, N.Y. 10012

THE NATIONAL PRISON PROJECT OF THE ACLU FOUNDATION
The NPP offers a comprehensive outline for prisoners seeking pre-sentence investigation reports, prison files, medical records and personal files held by the Federal Bureau of Prisons and the U.S. Parole Commission. NPP does not provide individual representation but will refer prisoners to local legal aid groups where requests for information from state authorities are involved –

1875 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Suite 410, Washington, D.C.
(202) 234-4830

Law schools around the country have clinics which may provide legal services. One example is –

INST. FOR PUBLIC INTEREST REPRESENTATION, GEORGETOWN UNIV. LAW CENTER
This program is a public interest law firm that operates out of Georgetown University’s law school. It is staffed by several full-time attorneys and law students. Although frequently involved in FOIA issues, the institute cannot give individual advice to those writing request or appeal letters. It will, however, provide representation (usually charging for court costs only) to individuals or groups involved in a significant FOIA dispute with an agency. The decision on whether to take a case will be based on the nature and significance of the documents sought and the importance and novelty of the legal issues –

600 New Jersey Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20001
(202) 662-9535

FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AGENCY ADDRESSES
If the agency you’re interested in does not appear here, you will be able to find the correct address by contacting either the local office of that agency or by contacting headquarters in Washington, D.C. Included here are the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). The CFR lists the policies for each agency and may be helpful in your research. The CFR can be found in any law library and many public libraries.

The Department of Justice provides an updated listed of FOIA Administrative Contacts by agency at http://www.usdoj.gov/foia/att_a.htm, as well as a collection of links to agency FOIA sites at http://www.usdoj.gov/foia/other_age.htm