|
We Update
Daily!
Custom Search
Chris S. Kenoyer. Owner
MMJ Patient,
Medical Activist,
Online Patients Advocate,
Online News Journalist
My
Personal Medical Bio
Follow Us Now On Twitter
@MedicalMMJMan
Email Us Here
olpwebs@yahoo.com
Or
Email Us Securely Here
olpwebs@Safe-mail.net
TV,
News, Press, Contact Info
********************************
Advertise Here
On OnlinePot
Rates As Low As $50 a Year
24/7 - 365 Days A Year
Of Sales!
*******************************************
Website Navigational Links
Main
Start Page 2
*******************************************
Parody's
Cartoons US
Government Grown Pot,
Term Papers,
School
Reports, & Thesis's On
Marijuana & Cannabis
*******************************************
Amsterdam
A to Z
*******************************************
Canadian
Marijuana
Websites
*******************************************
Church's
& Pot Cannabis
*******************************************
Co-Ops, Clinics, Dispensary's
*********************************************
Marijuana
Doctors & Clinics
*******************************************
Pot
Cooking Recipes
*******************************************
Drug
Testing A To Z
*******************************************
Pot Games
*******************************************
100's
Of Grow Guides
*******************************************
Latest
Marijuana News Reports
*******************************************
Hash A- Z
*******************************************
Cannabis
Legal Info, Drug
Lawyers, State, Federal Laws,
State
& Supreme Court Rulings
*******************************************
POW's
Of The MMJ
War!
*******************************************
Other
Marijuana Websites
Websites
Link
Exchange!
*******************************************
Medical
Marijuana
Studies,
Research
Report's, Medical
Cannabis Clinic Study's
*******************************************
Avoiding Online MOM
Scammers
Newly
Re-Updated Info!
*******************************************
The Politics Of
Contraband
Medical Marijuana In The Mail?
*******************************************
The
Hall Of Shame Section
The Online MOM Scammers
*******************************************
Online
MOM Providers Ads
*******************************************
Politicians
&
Voters Rights
*******************************************
Medical
Marijuana, Strains
*******************************************
The OG
Marijuana Strain Guide
*******************************************
800+
FAQ Growing Questions
*******************************************
Patients
Spiritual
Guidance,
Free Online
Crisis Help Center
*******************************************
Online
Marijuana Seed Banks
*******************************************
Maximum Security
Section
Just Updated!
*******************************************
Traveling
Tips, Guides, B & B's
*******************************************
Vaporizers
A To Z
*******************************************
Online Pot Video's & Movies
*******************************************
Please
Visit Our Sister Websites!
Maine
Patients Coalition.org
Reefer Madness Teaching
Museum.org
Listen Right Here Online!
To Original 1930-1950's
Reefer Madness Propaganda
Radio
Shows And Programs
Before TV There Were
"Radio Stars"
STOP SOPA!
********************************
OnlinePot Free Newsletter
The
Latest In MMJ News
Legal
Disclaimer
Guest Book
Translate text or web page go
to:
Language Tools
Google
Translations
Submissions & News Reports
Are Always
Gladly Accepted Here.
Is CBD? A Possible
Cure For
Breast Cancer?
And All The Other
Many
Forms & Types
Of Cancer?
Learn
More About " CBD" Here
Cancer Cured? A Cannabis Story
1999-2012 Copyright ©
All Rights Reserved.
No part of this site maybe used or
reproduced in whole or in part
without
the written consent of the
Copyright
Owner Chris Kenoyer
www.onlinepot.org
OnlinePot assumes no legal
liability
for
any products, or
information or
news
posted, services
offered,
Or
any contests or give away's offered.
| | Marijuana is Medicine Case
Law
State of Florida vs. Elvy Mussika
TAGS Medical Marijuana
Florida Supreme Court
Marijuana Case Law
Court Rulings
Florida
Legal Research
Cop Stops
Doctors
Vehicle Searches
Attorney General
US Supreme Court
District Court
State Court
Marijuana Court Rulings
9th district court
US Department Of Justice
DEA
Drug Lawyers
Legal Defenses
Case Rulings
 FLORIDA STATE DRUG TRAFFICKING LAWS RULED UNCONSTITUTIONAL
District Court Ruling
Return
To OnlinePot's Legal Section Main Page
Seventeen Judicial Circuit
In and
For Broward County, Florida
Case No. 68 4395 CFA 10
State of Florida vs. Elvy Mussika, Defendant
Mark F. Polen, Circuit Court Judge
Appearances:
Norman Elliott Kent, P.A., for Defendant
Carol
Wilhelm, A.S.A., State Attorney's Office
Dated: December 28, 1988
Opinion
On March 5, 1988, the defendant, Elvy Mussika, was arrested and charged with
cultivation of marijuana, in violation of Florida Statute ss893.13(1)(a). The
case came before the Court for trial on August 15, 1988. The Court heard
testimony from three witnesses, including the defendant. After due deliberation,
the Court found Ms. Mussika not guilty of the charges by reason of a defense of
medical necessity. The Court now renders the following decision.
Conclusion
One point I want to emphasize is that no one should interpret this decision
as the Court giving a green light to the consumption of marijuana. That is not
the message of this opinion. Marijuana use continues to be against the law. Ms.
Mussika's circumstances, while not unique, are somewhat unusual. The message of
this decision is that the law is flexible enough, and humane enough, to allow an
individual to preserve her eyesight with a substance that is generally illegal.
Indeed, this Court hopes that is decision, and the other decisions cited herein,
will encourage legislators and regulators to correct the anomaly in the law
which forces people trying to save their lives and senses into becoming
criminals.
The government is charged with a responsibility to see that its laws are
faithfully obeyed. And the Court does not dispute the government's legitimate
role in regulating drugs. But the absolute prohibition against marijuana's use,
even when such use may be therapeutically required to avoid grave and
irreversible injury, appears on its face to be irrational. Such a sweeping,
indiscriminate prohibition is not well founded.
Surely the Florida legislature, when it embraced such a total prohibition,
could not have foreseen the possibility that a socially abused substance like
marijuana might prove to be of critical medical value to patients confronting
life-threatening and sense-threatening diseases.
In our haste to rightfully prosecute those who profit from the social
trafficking and sale of illicit drugs we cannot become blind to the legitimate
medical needs of those who are afflicted by incurable diseases and require
appropriate medical care. To ignore the plight of such people renders the law
callous to the most basic of all human rights; the right of self-preservation.
Finally, the Court is deeply disturbed by the broader implications to the
testimony presented in this case. Medical necessity is a stringent, demanding
legal defense. The practice of medicine, however, cannot be predicted upon the
legal requirements of the medical necessity defense if it is to preserve health
in a rational, compassionate manner. As this decision, and the earlier decisions
cited herein illustrate, marijuana has "an accepted medical use in
treatment". Indeed, the evidence indicates marijuana is now being employed,
albeit illegally, by patients throughout the United States. In the vast majority
of such cases, these desperately ill people are being forced underground and
away from urgently needed medical supervision to acquire marijuana.
This is an intolerable, untenable legal situation. Unless legislators and
regulators heed these urgent human needs and rapidly move to correct the anomaly
arising from the absolute prohibition of marijuana which forces law-abiding
citizens into the streets - and criminality - to meet their legitimate medical
needs, cases of this type will become increasingly common in coming years. There
is a pressing need for a more compassionate, humane law which clearly
discriminates between the criminal conduct of those who socially abuse chemicals
and the legitimate medical needs of seriously ill patients whose welfare and
very lives may depend on the prudent therapeutic use of those very same chemical
substances.
Upon the basis of the foregoing discussion, the Court finds that the
defendant, Elvy Mussika, has established the defense of medical necessity.
Accordingly, it is the decision of this Court that she is not guilty of
violation of Florida Statute ss893.13(1)(a) , and the defendant is hereby
discharged.
Footnotes
1. These "experimental" procedures included the use of medical
and/or surgical therapies which are not yet approved by the FDA for general
medical use.
2. United States v. Randall, 104 Wash. Daily Rptr. 2249 (1976).
3. Based on testimony from Ms. Mussika, Dr. Palmberg and Mr. Randall it is
clear the defendant, Ms. Mussika, has made numerous attempts to acquire licit
access to marijuana to meet her legitimate medical needs. She asked a number of
physicians to assist her in acquiring prescriptive access to marijuana, but they
refused to assist her because of the tremendous paperwork and technical
knowledge involved in such an undertaking.
Desperate to prolong her sight, the defendant, at one point in 1987 telephone
the Hollywood Police Department to request their help in securing licit access
to marijuana.
Only after the defendant was arrested on March 5, 1988, did she learn from
Mr. Randall that her physician could request legal access to marijuana from the
Federal Food and Drug Administration. At this juncture Dr. Palmberg and Mr.
Randall agreed to assist her in filing for a Compassionate Investigational New
Drug "IND" from the FDA.
Despite the fact Dr. Palmberg filed his request with the FDA in April, 1988,
FDA had not as yet approved Dr. Palmberg's request for licit supplies of
marijuana to treat Ms. Mussika. At the time of this writing - and despite the
verdict of this Court - Ms. Mussika has yet to receive any legal marijuana from
FDA to meet her legitimate needs. The Court is greatly disturbed by the fact
that, because of federal inaction, Ms. Mussika must use illicit marijuana if she
is to save her sight. Such a situation is not legally tenable, much less moral.
|
Button Ads
